Profile photo of Hon. Robert L. McGahey, Jr. (Ret.)

Hon. Robert L. McGahey, Jr. (Ret.)

Arbitrator Mediator Special Master
Denver, CO, United States

About

Before entering private practice, this neutral served as a judge on the Second Judicial District Court in Denver for over two decades, presiding over a vast array of civil cases including multi-week jury trials and complex commercial litigation. His background includes extensive work in construction defect, insurance coverage, and professional malpractice. Prior to his judicial appointment, he spent 25 years as a trial attorney focusing on civil litigation, insurance defense, and product liability, bringing a total of nearly 50 years of legal expertise to his dispute resolution practice.

Practice Areas

Business & Commercial Construction Education Employment & Labor Insurance Personal Injury & Torts Real Estate & Property

Professional Experience

Neutral
JAMS
District Court Judge
Second Judicial District (Denver
CO)
Shareholder
Montgomery Little & McGrew
P.C.
Partner
Gaschler & McGahey
Associate/Partner
Sullivan & Sullivan

Publications Leadership

  • Adjunct Professor, University of Denver Sturm College of Law
  • Faculty Member, National Institute for Trial Advocacy (NITA)
  • Presenter, 'Effective Use of Exhibits in the Courtroom'
  • Author, 'The Art of the Opening Statement'
  • Chair, Civil Jury Instructions Committee, Colorado Supreme Court

Positioning Takeaways

A veteran judicial officer with nearly 50 years of combined experience on the bench and in private practice, specializing in construction and commercial law.

License & Certifications

  • Colorado State Bar
  • United States District Court for the District of Colorado
  • United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit
  • United States Supreme Court

Education

J.D.
University of Denver College of Law
1974
B.A.
Princeton University
1971

Distinction

One of the longest-serving civil trial judges in Denver's history with a reputation for handling high-stakes, multi-party construction and commercial cases.

Reputation

He is recognized by legal professionals for his deep understanding of courtroom dynamics, his fair-minded approach to complex legal issues, and his ability to facilitate settlements in emotionally charged or technically difficult disputes.