Profile photo of Andrew Nadolna, Esq.

Andrew Nadolna, Esq.

Arbitrator Mediator Special Master
New York, NY, United States

About

Andrew Nadolna possesses over 30 years of experience in the insurance industry, having transitioned to a full-time neutral role after a significant career as a senior insurance executive. He has presided over thousands of mediations involving complex multi-party disputes, high-stakes coverage issues, and diverse commercial litigation. His background includes overseeing major claims departments and managing significant litigation portfolios for global insurance carriers.

Practice Areas

Business & Commercial Civil Litigation Construction Healthcare & Life Sciences Insurance Personal Injury & Torts Technology & Cyber

Professional Experience

Neutral
JAMS
2020
Independent Mediator and Arbitrator
Andrew Nadolna ADR Services
2017–2020
Global Head of Casualty Claims
AIG
Head of Specialty Claims
2015–2017
AIG
2011–2015
Various Senior Executive Roles
AIG
Attorney
2005–2011
Private Practice
1989–2005

Publications Leadership

  • Frequent author for the New York Law Journal on insurance mediation topics
  • Speaker at the ABA Insurance Coverage Litigation Committee CLE Seminar
  • Presenter for the American College of Coverage Counsel (ACCC) annual meetings
  • Contributor to JAMS ADR Insights on cybersecurity and cyber insurance trends
  • Faculty member for various CLE programs focused on effective mediation strategies

Positioning Takeaways

Andrew Nadolna is a premier choice for insurance-related disputes due to his extensive executive-level experience at AIG. He is particularly effective in cases involving cyber liability, professional indemnity, and catastrophic casualty claims where technical insurance knowledge is critical for settlement.

License & Certifications

  • State Bar of New York
  • State Bar of New Jersey

Education

J.D.
Georgetown University Law Center
1989
B.A.
Johns Hopkins University
1986

Distinction

Recognized for his deep 'inside-the-industry' perspective as a former high-level insurance executive, which allows him to navigate complex coverage and valuation issues with unique authority.

Reputation

He is widely regarded by both plaintiff and defense counsel as a highly prepared, persistent, and fair neutral who excels at resolving emotionally charged and legally intricate insurance disputes.